It was a warm spring morning and I had already spent a few hours slipping between the huge wooden pillars of the forest following a fresh trail. The sun was getting high enough to send shafts of light down through the boughs and to warm, in places, the forest floor. With warmth comes the release of volatile oils and aromas, coaxed by the warm convections eddying in these islands of light. New scents trace the air. As I squatted between the large buttresses of a giant conifer I could smell warm pineapple. This was different. It triggered a thought: a hundred yards back amongst other conifers the smell of citrus zest was apparent as I pushed through its dense growth. Could I possibly identify these trees just by smell alone?
We spend much of our time indentifying plants by visual characteristics. We frequently overlook our other senses and the other physical aspects of a plant. Take conifers for instance – on casual inspection they look very similar. So much so that for many it is too much effort to tell them apart. But engaging with plants using your other senses can be of great use. I have noticed, very subtlely, that sound travels differently though old Douglas Fir compared to Norway Spruce – maybe its because of the texture of the bark, the shape of the tree or its foliage. As a tracker I have used sound to tell me that old, fallen twigs of the Western Hemlock tree (Tsuga heterophylla) are much more noisy to walk over than Norway Spruce (Picea abies) – a useful thing to know when you are stalking wild animals in the half-light of the forest. Now, I will often try to skirt around Western Hemlock to avoid the added disturbance.
Similarly, and probably more usefully, we can use smell to help us confirm which conifer or evergreen is in front of us. Particularly useful if you are then going on to safely use it to make some satisfying and tasty ‘needle tea’. By simply crushing the foliage you tell you alot about its origin. Add this to some other indicators and it will give you more confidence in your identification – even possibly in the dark!
- Really intense citrus (grapefruit), sweet, hot, rich resinous, and very fruity
- Definite tangerine peel/zest
- Really intense, rich and fruity
- Not as intense as Sitka. Resinous, bright grassy-herbal, slight camphor-like notes, some citrus pith quality when crushed. NB: some samples had a slightly animal/feral/’bo’ quality to them which was not pleasant but might help distinguish it.
- Herby, pine fresh, slightly grassy
Western Red Cedar
- Intense dried pineapple
- Sour, mousey, parsley, unpleasant (it got its name because it smelled similar to the deadly umbellifer plant ‘Hemlock’ of the same name but it is NOT related)
- Distinct lemon-zest scent
- Apples & lemons
- No strong scent
- tbc – when the needles come out in spring!
*Not the Hemlock of Socrates fame – this is the umbellifer plant (same member as the carrot family: Apiaceae family (formerly Umbelliferae)). One is a big evergreen tree and one is a plant – please don’t confuse as the plant is very toxic!
Footnotes: use the ‘top tips’ below in conjunction with the above and you should be well on your way to successfully distinguishing which are which.
Sitka Spruce (Picea sitchensis) is the 5th largest conifer species in the world and is one of these few who have been documented to reach 300 feet. It acquires its name from the community of Sitka, Alaska. It is a long-lived tree which can grow in excess of 700 years.
- VERY spikey needles – very painful to grip – more so than any other
- Needles are flattened compared to the Norway Spruce
- Blue-green above the needles and VERY blue-white underneath the needles
- Slender pendulous cones (with thin flexible scales) 6–10 cm long – usually half the length of Norway Spruce cones
- Bark is thin and scaley and flakes off in small cirular plates that somtimes litter the ground underneath the tree.
Norway Spruce (Picea abies)
- Quadrangular in cross-section (not flattened), and dark green on all four sides with inconspicuous stomatal lines
- The cones are 9–17 cm long (the longest of any spruce)
- The needles are stiff and prickly but nowhere near as painful to grasp as the needle-like sitka.
Western Red Cedar (Thuja plicata)
- Very different from the other confiers listed here – similar to Cypress (or Leylandii) in there are no needles but the fronds (divided many times on the branch) are formed into many overlapping platelets.
- Very flattened profile to the leaves and the fronds themselves are quite flat and two-dimensional.
- Can have shaggy bark that is good for cordage
- The wood is very aromatic
Douglas Fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii)
- Soft needles that are flat, with no groove in the end of the needles (unlike the Grand Fir for instance)
- Medium length – longer that Sitka and Norway Spruce Needles
- Grow pretty much all around the twig rather than in two ranks like the Grand Fir
- Deeply fissured cracked bark plates when old but relatively smooth and covered in resin blisters when younger
- Cones have distinct ‘adder tongue’ or mouse tale/legs sticking out from under the scales. These are bracts and confirm that it is a Douglas Fir.
Western Hemlock (Tsuga heterophylla)
- Unpleasant smell
- Occasional ‘upside down’ leaf in line and on the twig
- Very short needles and sometimes presents itself as a bit ‘messy’ on the branch
- Growing tip of the tree is characteristically droopy
Grand Fir (Abies grandis)
- Needles form two fairly unform ranks either side of the twig
- Needles are soft, notched/grooved at their tips and dark green and shiny on top, pale green-white bands underneath, soft.
- Very small (2mm) buds.
- Old cones tend to disintegrated easily
Scots Pine (Pinus sylvestris)
- Large flat metallic grey plates of bark with fissures
- Pinky bark towards top of tree
- Needles held in pairs and are quite short for a pine (but longer than the other conifers listed here)
- The needles are long and twisted and are held in bunches or ‘brushes’ rather than in ranks along the twig.
- Very robust cones with angular ‘armoured’ feel to the scales.
- Often bare trunk until high up then a lofty roundish/flat dome
Yew (Taxus baccata)
- No real smell to foliage
- Has little white-green buds along the twig (about 2mm across) – these turn into red fruits rather than cones
- Usually a small to medium-sized tree
- Needles are soft but with a pointed end (which is not sharp)
- Bark is thin and scaly and brown and comes off in small flakes aligned with the stem/trunk
European Larch (Larix decidua)
- Many, many small ovoid cones on branches and these are erect rather than penduous
- Old cones can remain on tree for several years
- Deciduous (one of only a few conifers that are such as the Bald Cypress, Dawn Redwood and Tamarack)
- Needles are soft and held in brushes along the twig and are light green